7th Circuit Sides with RWI Insurer, Affirming Denial of Coverage Where Seller Failed to Obtain Required Consent to Settlement
September 7, 2017 – As anticipated in the May 23, 2017 Law360 article about the case, written by Butler Rubin attorneys Jason Dubner and Mark Schwartz, the Seventh Circuit in an opinion issued last week in Ratajczak v. Beazley Solutions Ltd. (No. 16-3418) clarified the duties of an issuer of representation and warranty insurance (“RWI”) accused of bad faith and breach of contract by its policyholder. The Court unambiguously sided with the insurer.
The issue facing the Court was whether Beazley’s sell-side warranty and indemnity policy provided coverage for the pre-litigation settlement the sellers reached with the buyers following post-acquisition allegations of fraud and breach of warranties contained in the stock purchase agreement. Beazley’s policy provided that it was not bound by settlements that it does not approve, and the Court found that Beazley not only did not approve the settlement but was not even notified of the claim until settlement talks were almost complete. The sellers argued that Beazley could not prove prejudice from the delay, but the Court held that prejudice was not required under controlling New York law. According to Judge Easterbrook’s opinion, “[t]he approval requirement is absolute.” (Slip Op., at 8.)
While at least in certain jurisdictions, RWI insurers may take comfort from Ratajzak in the enforceability of such “consent-to-settle” provisions in their policies, the Court did recognize that insurers may have a duty to look beyond the express allegations of an underlying complaint to determine whether a breach of a Fundamental Representation is triggered. Although the Ratajczak Court concluded there were no such implicit or express allegations in this case, if the settled allegations had been part of a filed complaint, rather than merely threatened litigation, the Court’s opinion suggests that the insured could have tried to establish a link between the buyer’s allegations and a breach of a covered Fundamental Representation, such as one related to the accuracy of the seller’s books and records. Accordingly, Ratajzak provides lessons going forward to both the policyholder and the insurer in RWI transactions.
Some of the content on this site is considered Attorney Advertising under the applicable rules of certain states. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Butler Rubin assumes no responsibility for the accuracy or timeliness of any information provided herein. The information contained herein is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice or a substitute for legal counsel.
Online readers should not act upon this information without seeking professional counsel. This information is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. While we would like to hear from you, we cannot represent you until we know that doing so will not create a conflict of interest. Accordingly, do not use any of the supplied e-mail interfaces to send us any confidential information until you speak with one of our attorneys and receive our authorization to send that information to us.
Sites listed as hypertext links herein are not under the control of Butler Rubin. Accordingly, Butler Rubin can make no representation concerning the quality, safety or suitability of the content of these sites nor can the fact that Butler Rubin has included this link serve as an endorsement by Butler Rubin of any of these sites. Butler Rubin is providing this site, the information, listings, and links contained herein only as a convenience to you.
Some of the content of this site is considered advertising material under the applicable rules of certain states. The content, original images and their arrangement herein are protected and owned by Butler Rubin.
2. Information collected
We may collect the following personal data when you visit our website: (a) Personal data provided when you complete forms available on our website; (b) Personal data you provide when you contact us; (c) Personal data relating to: (i) your application for employment at Butler Rubin, (ii) our Diversity Scholar award; and/or (iii) your attendance at a Butler Rubin event; (d) Details of visits to our website, including the volume of traffic received, logs and the resources which have been accessed.
3. How we use your information
We use information you provide to better understand your needs and provide you with better service. With the exception of vendors providing hosting, database management and development services related to the operation of these websites, we will not disclose, sell or rent any of your personal data to any third party unless approved by you or required by law.
4. Transfer of personal data
5. Links to other sites
We may provide links to other websites for your information or convenience. Such websites are independently operated and not under our control. We are not responsible for the content of these websites or any products or services offered through them.
8. Our commitment to data security
To prevent unauthorized access, maintain data accuracy, and ensure the correct use of information, the Firm uses commercially appropriate physical, electronic, and managerial procedures to safeguard and secure the information we collect online. Unfortunately, the transmission of information via the Internet is not completely secure. However, we have put in place various security procedures as set out in this policy. Although we will do our best to protect your personal data, we cannot guarantee the security of your data transmitted to our website; any transmission is at your own risk. Once we have received your information, we will use strict procedures and security features to try to prevent unauthorized access.
9. Our commitment to children’s privacy
We do not seek to collect or maintain information on our website from those we know are under 18, and no part of our website is structured to attract anyone under 13.
The Extranet is a secure (password-protected) and private (client-specific) portal for Butler Rubin’s clients who want to share information directly with the firm. Butler Rubin’s Extranet uses SSL encryption to ensure the confidentiality and integrity of all communications between your web browser and our Extranet server.